Created on 11-03-2016 - Last Update 03-01-2023

 

 

_ Broadway _

 

Now here is a truly “rare” Bingo and one with a bit of a sketchy history and legitimacy`…As you can see, I reference it here as Broadway

If you look elsewhere for this game, both Phil and the IPDB refer to it as Broadway 51`…and I assume that is based upon its release date`

 

This game kind of popped up out of nowhere in 2016 when Dennis Dodel shared his and now we know of (3) total and have a photo of a 4th

 

Another name tied to this Bingo by the old-dogs like Freddy Bailey is 42nd & Broadway

Which is interesting, since most of the known history is tied to New York and that Broadway is clearly the theme of this Bingo

 

Credit and thanks for the “best” detail goes out to Dennis & the IPDB`…Read the write-up on the IPDB`…just excellent`

 

Note: I refer to this Bingo as Broadway due to the advertising in Billboard and due to the name on the known schemtaic`

 

Note: For some reason, in my mind, I have the theory that a “single buyer” purchased all of these machines`

 

 

 

OK, this first photo is the Bingo owned by BingoButch

 

 

I wanted to start here with the theme, point to the comment from Bill on Phil’s webpages, and share that Freddy’s game was purchased in New Jersey

 Since they support a crazy idea I have always had`…that all of these Bingos were from New York and purchased by a “single-buyer”

 

Likely all these things are part of why I think like I do`…They all seem to frame the Market, bounding it to New York

 

OK, if I am correct, then why is there a machine in Texas with Dennis, and a machine in New Orleans for Evauation

Well, I think that comes down to this may not be a true Bally machine`…But as they went to Market it, they still ran it through the paces`

 

It would be another stretch, but maybe Dennis’s machine is the New Orleans Bingo

 

 

 

_ Regardless, this is a very interesting Bingo _

 

And I say this because all the machines we see are different`…Very different, staring with the base configuration`

 

Here are a couple of the pictures that Dennis sent to the IPDB

This is the 1st of the machines that popped up`

 

Broadway Cabinet - Right Broadway Playfield

 

The cabinet and playfiled from the 1951 Ball Bright Lights`…Released in May of 1951

 

The guys report that the interanls in this machine are ripped-up, chopped-up, and kind of thrown toegther`

Well of course, go ahead and convert a 6-Card to a 1-Card game`…Laugh, you kind of have to “gut” the thing`

 

I am not 100% sure, but this is “likely” the machine we see on Phil’s webpages`

 

 

Here is Freddy Bailey’s machine with ties back to J.H. Keeney`…Bally’s silent. secret, Partner

This is the 2nd of the machines that popped up`

 

https://www.tapatalk.com/groups/ballybingofff/download/file.php?dt=display&id=86

 

broadway 51.jpg

 

That is a cabinet from Keeney’s Lite-a-Line and Holiday

 

broadway 51.jpg1.jpg

 

And the playfield here in from Keneey Holiday

 

31944369_2440866395938800_3818565941524955136_n

 

OK, this is another interim configuration`…Bally backglass and Keeney cabinet and playfield`

As this game was being cobbled together, it seems that Bally still worked at converting Bright Lights

 

Now, this begs the question: Why would Bally/Keeney also work to covert some Keeney games`

And this adds to and starts supporting my crazy theory that Bally was scrambling to capture a “sales opportunity” in a big hury`

 

If true`…you might just do something like this`…start woking with a competitior to get something in place`

This machine here might be a 1st or 2nd revison on a “fast track” to respond to a potential sale`…a huge order`

 

Another question is why didn’t Bally post any pictures in the advertsiments in Billboard Magazine for Broadway

All of these games are likely the answer, they are all prototypes, mock-ups`…that Bally didn’t have a “finished” product`

 

What we do know: Is this is the “Freddy Bailey” version of the Bingo`…and is it our only “known” example of a machine from the New York area`

So, were these the games that “were seen all over New York” – There is a good chance`

 

 

 

Here is the machine owned by BingoButch and it seems to be “all” Bally

This is the 3rd of the machines that popped up`

 

126481707_3813803905305584_5930559769823038140_n.jpg

 

Yes, that looks like a more mature Bingo`…Playfield and backglass that really match - Nice`

 

126437061_3813804001972241_7627000905363226358_n.jpg

 

Bally everything`…Including a “1951” playfield specially made for this Bingo

“Blue” verses the “Red” 1951 Bright Lights

 

Mike says that this “blue” playfiled was for the dedicated Broadways 51 and in a follow-up message`

Mentions`…that, every other one that I ever seen was converted from a bright lights and he has never seen one that was factory`

 

Very interesting`…Part of the mystery, suggesting that Bally never finished/produced their Broadway 51

 

33227820-547f-48f9-b9ba-5ae9249632c8-AP21321709362444

 

Well, everyone was curious when these games popped up and there was talk`

Image 1 (2)

Hmmm`….a bit more mystery: The serial number on the machine Dennis helped post is A2331

Image 1

So, the story fills in a bit more and gets a bit more convoluted, laugh`…good-and-bad`

Still a lot of unknowns`…and still maybe more questions than answers`

 

 

OK, once I knew what to look for`…I stated going through my old archives and found this image`

       This is the 4th machine I mentioned`…the “test site” game Bally deployed in New Orleans

 

Photo courtesy of Maunsel White

 

broadway 51.jpg2.jpg

 

New Orleans Jazz Club circa 1951

 

So, this shows us that things were progressing`…shows us Bally’s engineering was involved and they were working their process`

Working to develop a Bally Broadway and as such, sending games down south for evaluation`…on-site testing and feedback`

 

 New Orleans was the main test area for the Bally Bingos – Take a close look at that Bally Bright Lights; quite a bit of it was masked-off to shield its identity`

A common thing they did back then, to keep other coin-op companies from spying`…I wonder why the Broadway was so exposed`…Hmmm

 

 

 

_ OK, so what do we have here`…What does it all mean`…Well let me complete my Guesswork _

 

Various coin-op vendors list this game “for sale” in Billboard starting in 1951-08, but Bally dosen’t post an ad`

Bally doesn’t post a picture, any pictures and this is the “only” Bingo that, that is true for`

 

To me, that suggests that this game was on a fast track, that Bally didn’t really have a finished product`

 

We have (3) actual machines with (3) different configurations`…One of which is from a competitor J.H. Keeney

And all of the machines are 6-Cards games being converted to 1-Card games`

 

To me, that suggests that this game was on a fast track, that Bally didn’t really have a finished product`

 

Maybe Bally doesn’t have parts, materials, manufacturing capacity`…So, they start working with their Secert Partner

Maybe working with Keeney is the only way for them to capture and respond to big 1951 sales opportunity`

 

So, maybe they are scrambling and it is why we see different machines`…Maybe what we see are a few “early prototypes and iterations”

Things ramping up, before Bally’s engineering can finally catch up`

 

And just maybe they never do`…later Mke texts me “He’s never seen a factory game”

 

To me, all of this suggests that this game was on a fast track, that Bally didn’t really have a finished product`

 

 

_ Freddy just sent me this text here in 2023 _

 

Danny, Keeney made the first 6 card Bingo called Holiday in 1951 Bally took the cabinet from that model and rewired it and called it 42nd & Broadway, Bally made the first 25 hole bingo in 1937 called Line Up, that machine was designed by Herb Breitstein then Don Holder developed a circuit testing feature that took Bally to the front building Bingo's Herb and Don later joined Westronics along with my late partner in Las Vegas Mickey Wichinsky along with Billy O'Donnell who was president of Bally at that time. the only two major bingo game manufacturers that survived was Bally and United through the 1960's. Hope I have helped you a little bit, I am developing a new bingo that I am hoping will take over in the illegal Video Poker market that is dying.

 

My one came from a guy in New Jersey, so it is very possible it came from the New York area, my machine was defiantly a converted Keeney Holiday/Light-A-Line, there was a lot of parts with the Keeney name on them.

 

If you do not know, Freddy is old-school and knows these games`…he was there from the beginning, tied in with the Bingo Community

Likely that is why he happens to have one of these`…Connections and one of the  rarest of all the Bally Bingos

 

 

It’s my guess that all of the Bright Lights were conversions as Bally was scrambling`

Except maybe Mike’s with the “blue” playfield, which I think is the machine Bally wanted to finish`

 

It is my guess that Bally “actually sold” the Keeney Holiday conversions that matches Freddy’s Bingo

I further “toss out” that the “big rush” was to meet a sales order from a single-buyer in New York

And that, that is the reason we do not see a “ton of machines” left over today`

 

 If a single owner had all of these machines and/or they were all concentrated (located) in one area`…in New York

They could have easily all went “end-of-life” together`…either puleed by the owner and/or gutted/scrapped

back in the crazy New York “gambling” history and the “purging” that is well documented`

 

 

As usual, laugh, I throw out that this is all crazy conjecture and “that I maybe completely wrong here”

 

Although said, you know I like a good story and mine is plauasible`…too bad we may never know`

 

 

_ Here are some dates and detail from Billboard Magazine _

 

 

I am not too sure if this timeline helps or convolutes the story further`

 

Broadway gets mentioned 3-months after Bright Lights is released`…a very long time in the Bingo World

In the meantime, Bally was working on Coney Island and starts advertising Bright Spot in December

 

These guys are busy, these Bingos are getting very popluar and (5) companies are vying for that business – It’s 1951

 

Bally never releases a final version of Broadway 51 from their factory and they never advertise it`

Yet we know they were out on Route in numbers, in the New York area`

 

The only example of a machine from the New York area is a converted Keeney Holiday

and Keeney Lite-a-Line has full ads for this entire period, so likely they have materials`

 

But along with your cabinet, you need a 25-hole playfield, and that’s where Holiday fits in`

It also maybe a timing thing on the “sale” too – Quite a coincidence that “all” mention of Broadway stops`

 

So am I correct, was Bally scrambling to make a “one-time” sell to a “one-time” buyer`

Did they use Keeney parts to finished the deal`…Were the machines all destroyed in a New York purge`

 

People talk about the “secret” partnership Bally had with Keeney`…well it sounds like that started right here`

 

_ There is more than a little mystery in this Story _

 

Jay Stafford got me looking again at Billboard Magazine`…Thank you`

I don’t know how many times I have read through the 1951 issues before`…and everytime over-looked Broadway

 

_ Billboard 1951-08-04 _

 

1951-08-04 BB Bally Broadway

 

 

 

I love this next one`…3-years after this game pops up, the software guys run with it`

 

Dated October 2019`

 

https://www.pinballnirvana.com/forums/attachment.php?attachmentid=7356&d=1570985002

 

Broadway 51 BINGO now updated for VPX. Plays “EXACTLY” like the VP9 version did. A TON had to be updated for this one to work right but it plays wonderfully. Enjoy!

 

druadic

 

Will and the guys are quick, they always have been – Sweet`

 

 

 

 

 

_ Trivia _

 

Interesting, and another sign that this is not a 100% design from Bally

This is the “only” Bally Bingo that had a noise adjustment: “Turn the adjustment screw for desired sound effects!”

 

Laugh, what, on an American Bingo – “Not Enough Sound”

 

 

_ Trivia _

Bally never released a photo/ad of “their” 1951 Broadway Bingo

The “only” Bingo from that period where this is the case`…I bet things happened way too quickly`

It really wasn’t their design, I think they helped Keeney meet a “specific” one-time order`

 

 

 _ Other links on this Website _

http://danny.cdyn.com/42nd%20broadway%20bingo.htm

http://danny.cdyn.com/Broadway%201951.htm

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

~